REPORTS

OF

Cases Heard and Determined

BY THE

SUPREME COURT

OF

SOUTH CAROLINA

VOLUME CXI.

CONTAINING CASES OF APRIL AND OCTOBER, 1917, TERM.

J

Copyright, 1920

BY THE R. L. BRYAN COMPANY

SEP 3 1920

CIRCUIT JUDGES.

FIRST CIRCUIT-HON. I. W. BOWMAN.
SECOND CIRCUIT-HON. H. F. RICE.
THIRD CIRCUIT-HON. JOHN S. WILSON.
FOURTH CIRCUIT-HON. T. H. SPAIN'.
FOURTH CIRCUIT-HON. EDWARD McIVER.
FIFTH CIRCUIT-HON. W. H. TOWNSEND.
SIXTH CIRCUIT-HON. ERNEST MOORE.
SEVENTH CIRCUIT-HON. T. S. SEASE.

EIGHTH CIRCUIT-HON. FRANK B. GARY.

NINTH CIRCUIT HON. R. WITHERS MEMMINGER.

TENTH CIRCUIT--HON. GEORGE E. PRINCE.

ELEVENTH CIRCUIT-HON. J. W. DEVORE.

TWELFTH CIRCUIT-HON. S. W. G. SHIPP.

THIRTEENTH CIRCUIT-HON. T. J. MAULDIN.
FOURTEENTH CIRCUIT-HON. JAS. E. PEURIFOY.

ATTORNEY GENERAL.

HON. SAMUEL M. WOLFE.

ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL.