 | William Carl Placher - 1989 - Страниц: 188
...problem, a problem that shows the fallacy of that position. As Davidson puts it, "Nothing . . . could count as evidence that some form of activity could...evidence that that form of activity was not speech behavior." 40 If I want to claim that the Martians have a language at all, I will need to make arguments... | |
 | Simon Evnine - 1991 - Страниц: 216
...Putting the question in terms of interpretability of language, he writes that 'nothing . . . could count as evidence that some form of activity could...that that form of activity was not speech behaviour' (1974a, p. 185). What justifies this is the theory of content that has emerged through the last three... | |
 | Samuel Fleischacker - 1992 - Страниц: 280
...divorced from its place in the logical network of other thoughts." 14 Furthermore, "nothing...could count as evidence that some form of activity could...evidence that that form of activity was not speech behavior." (ITI 185) Again, this position leaves open the possibility of a large chunk of beliefs being... | |
 | Michael N. Forster - 1998 - Страниц: 688
...schemes or complete failures of intertranslatability of languages, "nothing, it may be said, could count as evidence that some form of activity could...evidence that that form of activity was not speech behavior. If this were right, we probably ought to hold that a form of activity that cannot be interpreted... | |
 | Paul D. Murray - 2004 - Страниц: 300
...in fact, nor might potentially be any such utterly incomparable conceptual schemes.73 Any supposed evidence that 'some form of activity could not be interpreted in our language' should more naturally be taken as evidence that the particular activity in question was not in fact... | |
 | Simon Blackburn - 2005 - Страниц: 272
...statement of the argument: It is tempting to take a very short line indeed: nothing, it may be said, could count as evidence that some form of activity could...evidence that that form of activity was not speech behaviour.3 This sounds shockingly complacent, and Davidson himself draws back a little: 'as fiat the... | |
 | Karin Johannesson - 2007 - Страниц: 276
...choice of words. In developing his argument, Davidson points out that 'nothing, it may be said, could count as evidence that some form of activity could...evidence that that form of activity was not speech behaviour.'52 We do not conceive of a language that we cannot translate as a language, that is, as... | |
| |
It is tempting to take a very short line indeed : nothing, it may be said, could count as evidence that some form of activity could not be interpreted in our language that was not at the same time evidence that that form of activity was not speech behaviour. 