In 1694 Sir John Somers, writing to the REV. RICHARD SCOTT (11 S. ix. 430, 498). 1489-90. "It. a punchon of Iron wt abrode-There is, it is true, some probability that arowe hede grauyn therein." 1564-5. Itm. pd. for a hammer & a chesell & mending the Brode Arowhedd to saye the Tynne. iijs. iiijd." the Dublin graduate mentioned by MR. HIPWELL in his kind reply was identical with the Rev. Richard Scott, M.A., who 1797, but positive testimony to that effect came from Fakenham to King's Lynn in has not hitherto been forthcoming. Although the above references in no way refer to the broad arrow as the "King's mark," it is at this early date evidently one used under authority, and is first spoken of enable some of your readers to clear the A few additional clues may, perhaps, in 1474 as the "forfet " mark, wherewith, matter up one way or another. The it is supposed, all wares of inferior metal Richard Scott, aged 20, who entered Dublin or workmanship were branded, and ulti-University as a Sizar on 16 June, 1778. was mately forfeited by the maker and melted the son of a farmer in co. Clare; he had been down. Secondly, in 1564 it is mentioned educated previously by a Mr. Numan (Dublin as the mark used for assaying the tin, and University Matriculation Books). more directly implies under royal authority than when it was used as a company mark for confiscated wares. HOWARD H. COTTERELL, F.R.Hist.S. Foden Road, Walsall. 6 "BLANDANDERED (11 S. ix. 487).In Kipling's story With the Main Guard (see Soldiers Three') the Irishman Mulvaney, a splendid soldier ruined by the habit of drinking, helps his comrades through a night of terrible heat in India by his wonderful gift of story-telling. On being complimented upon what he has done, "he looked at me wearily; his eyes were sunk in his head, and his face was drawn and white. Eyah,' said he, I've blandandhered thim through the night somehow, but can thim that helps others help thimselves? Answer me that, Sorr!"" C. L. S. LOMBARD STREET BANKERS: SIR STEPHEN EVANCE (11 S. ix. 230, 272, 298, 373, 453, 494). The Calendars of Treasury Papers and of State Papers, William and Mary, contain a number of entries in reference to Sir Stephen Evance-or Evans, as the name is more frequently spelt in these volumes. Peterborough. R. S. H. PROVIDENCE : THE VOYAGE OF THE CAPT. BLIGH (11 S. ix. 489). In the June catalogue of second-hand books on sale by R. Hall of Tunbridge Wells occurs the following: 66 Bligh (Lt. W.) Voyage to the South Sea for the purpose of Conveying the Bread-Fruit Tree to the West Indies in H.M.S. the Bounty, including account of the Mutiny and subsequent voyage-plate and charts, 4to, 1st ed., 1792.” Possibly this may be the book to which MR. TEW refers. A copy is in the London Library. A. COLLINGWOOD LEE. Waltham Abbey, Essex. DIDO'S PURCHASE OF LAND (11 S. ix. 47, 353, 474,).-See 'Die Historie von einer Frau genannt Melusine' in 'Deutsche Volksbuecher,' Langewiesche, 1912, p. 378. This is a reprint of the 1456 German version, by Tuering von Ruggeltingen, of a contemporary French version of the Latin of Jean d'Arras. There is a curious woodcut illustrating the measuring of the land. D. L. GALBREATH. "IONA" (11 S. ix. 490). In the Gaelic ELFOU (11 S. ix. 470).-Perhaps Edfû is language at the present day it is called "I" meant, which lies between Luxor and the (pronounced as e in English), which simply First Cataract on the Nile. The Greek name means island," but the ancient form of one of the nomes of Upper Egypt was "Ioua," used by Adamnan, the ninth Apollinopolis Magna. Ptolemy IV., PhiloAbbot of Iona, who died in the year 703, pator (B.c. 222), founded a temple there. is still occasionally employed. A. R. BAYLEY. CONSTANCE RUSSELL. "Ioua " is a genuine form, ordinarily used by Adamnan in mentioning Ioua insula, the island of Hy, an adjective with a fem. termination derived from a root-form Iou. But in his second preface he says that Columba was homonymous with Iona (Jonah) the prophet, whose name in Hebrew signifies "dove." This explanation, coupled with the connexion between Columba and his island, led to the erroneous form "Iona,” and the conversion of an adjective into a place-name. J. T. F. Durham. OLD ETONIANS (11 S. ix. 489).-(11) Robert Shapland Carew, admitted 5 July, 1765, left 1767, was only son of Shapland C. of Castle Boro, co. Wexford, by Dorothy, dau. and coheir of Isaac Dobson. He was M.P. Makshufa, Harefield Road, Uxbridge. 66 National Liberal Club. PRIVY COUNCILLORS (11 S. ix. 449, 490).— MR. A. L. HUMPHREYS at the latter reference is in error in his statement that a Privy Councillor must be a natural-born subject of Great Britain." A notable exception was Max Müller, who was appointed as a naturalized British subject. I saw him in his robes after the honour was bestowed on him, and he was justly proud of the distinction. His wish that we should meet again in Florence was, I painfully recall, his last adieu to me on that occasion. WILLIAM MERCER. The engraving evidently represents the famous temple at Edfu, on the left bank of the Nile, in Upper Egypt. Edfu is the Απόλλωνος πόλις οι Απόλλωνος πόλις μεγάλη of the Greeks, and the Apollinis of Pliny, Nat. Hist.,' 5, 9 (11), 60. EDWARD BENSLY. [Several other correspondents take what Elfou seems certainly the right view-that is simply a misprint.] WEST INDIAN FAMILIES (11 S. ix. 489).See Sketch Pedigrees of some of the Early Settlers in Jamaica,' by Noël B. Livingston (Kingston, Educational Supply Co., 1909, 8vo, pp. 139, iv.). A wealth of material, admirably indexed, will be found in the for public examination at the Record Office Slave Compensation Papers, made available 1913. They comprise 1,847 volumes, and are catalogued under T. 71. in March, 123, Pall Mall, S.W. J. M. BULLOCH. RAWDON FAMILY (11 S. ix. 428, 475).-In Wilson and Spence's History of York,' 1788, vol. ii. p. 433, will be found the following monumental inscriptions in the church of St. Crux (Holy Cross), York, concerning some members of the above family : "Laurence Rawdon, late of this city, Alderman, who departed this life in the 58th year of his age, July 5th, 1626. and two daughters, Roger, Robert, Marmaduke, Margery, his wife, by whom he had three sons Elizabeth, and Mary. She deceased on the 17th April, 1644; Also the body of Elizabeth, her grandchild, daughter of Sir Roger Jacques, Knt., who deceased in the 20th year of (her) age, Oct. 20th, 1651." Tomas Rawdon was Sheriff of York in 1615; Christopher Rawdon was Sheriff in 1739. In 1628 Sir Roger Jacques, merchant, served the office of Sheriff, and in 1639 he was Lord Mayor. WM. NORMAN. 11 S. X. JULY 4, 1914.] NOTES AND QUERIES. Notes on Books. 66 machine 'Second Characters.' Edited by Shaftesbury's Benjamin Rand. (Cambridge University Press, 78. 6d. net.) THE present volume brings us a real contribution to the available literature of the early eighteenth It comprises four treatises on art and century. manners or rather three treatises and the material for a fourth-the work of the last year of Shaftesbury's life, which was spent, for the sake of his declining health, at Naples. Of these treatises the first, the Letter concerning Design,' was printed for the first time in the fifth edition Chaof the author's best-known book, the racteristics'; and the second, The Judgment of Hercules,' was published in French in the Journal des Sçavans for November, 1712, appearing in English form separately in 1713, and in the second edition of the Characteristics in 1714. The fourth treatise, Plastics -inchoate, but none the less clear as to intent, and of wider range than the others-is published here for the first time, as are also the notes of the design for grouping the four together as a single work under the title of Second Characters.' no 66 in are which We on the "five parts in painting," which includes the machine The formlessness of the most important part of the book, and that which will be new to students, shows itself, very suggestively, as something of a Dr. Rand, who has already done important work in regard to Shaftesbury, gives a sufficient Introduction. Shaftesbury's name-on the whole a deservedly high one-gains by this addition The Judgment of Herto his achievement. cules may strike the modern reader as enunciating rather obvious principles in regard to unity and propriety in the treatment of an historical scene in painting; these principles did not, how-positive advantage. self-evident to Shaftesbury's contemporaries, and, even now, if used as a test in criticizing the new or newly approved work which occupies attention at the present day, might prove to be not so much ignored of set The beginning of the essay; purpose as neglected. with its distinction of the possible for the artist's portrayal, remains admirable and suggestive. ever, appear so average. 66 moments The Letter' on design is virtually a confession of faith in the soundness of æsthetic perception and judgment in the people at large-remarkable as coming from a man of Shaftesbury's position, whom ill-health, too-excluding him from public work-might have been expected to render somewhat narrowly fastidious in his estimate of the Moreover, he has the insight to perceive the dependence of a people's soundness in art Tablet of upon their civic rectitude and wisdom. Shaftesbury's translation of the Cebes' is given in the third place-in lieu of the Appendix concerning the Emblem of Cebes,' which remained unexecuted at his death. This enables the student to acquaint himself with an allegory which, in Shaftesbury's view, offered considerable opportunity for what we may call "creative comment," as well as here and there a pithy, suggestive counsel, though it cannot be pretended that, in itself, it is anything but a dull and frigid scheme for an interpretation of human life. Paper for the Discussion of Current Religious and Comment and Criticism: a Cambridge Quarterly Theological Questions. (Longmans, 6d.) THIS number (Vol. II. No. 1, May), appears in a new form, the object of which is to render the article on the exact import of the historicity of the preservation of copies practicable. It contains an Gospel, entitled Under Pontius Pilate,' by Prof. Burkitt; a plea for the reconstruction of English Ecclesiastical Courts, from the pen of Mr. Leslie: a suggestive paper by Mr. W. Spens on current an appreciation and criticism by Mr. H. L. Pass of Mr. Knox's recent book Some Loose Stones'; and controversy, as delivered in the recent pamphlets by Dr. Bethune-Baker, Dr. Sanday, and Bishop. Gore. MR. E. T. JAQUES, who is a solicitor of the Supreme Court, has made an interesting contribution Charles Dickens in Chancery, an account of Dickens's to Dickens literature by giving, under the title of proceedings in respect of the Christmas Carol,' to which he has added some gossip in relation to the old Law Courts at Westminster. Messrs. Longmans are the publishers, and the price is one Mr. Jaques is better known to our shilling net. readers as "Christian Tearle," the author of The Pilgrim from Chicago' and 'The Gardens of Gray's Inn.' MESSRS. A. & C. BLACK send The Social Guide for the present year, edited by Mrs. Hugh Adams and Miss Edith A. Browne. The 'Guide' includes the Indian seasons, Egypt, and Continental resorts. The price is half-a-crown net. The Cornhill Magazine begins with the first chapters of a novel entitled Two Sinners,' by Mrs. Ritchie. It starts out pretty well. The poem A True Dream,' from the unpublished remains of Mrs. Browning's early work, is several degrees better as poetry than the relics hitherto exhumed. Mr. A. C. Benson has some graceful commonplaces about old buildings in a paper called 'The Beauty of Age,' and Julia Cartwright contributes one of her pleasant studies of the Italian Renaissance in 'Cardinal Bembo and his Villa.' Mr. Stephen Paget in the first instalment of a series called The New Parents' Assistant' makes several sound and shrewd remarks which, however, are nearly lost in a mass of quasi-humorous illustration and paradox, which for some reason or other remains rather unconvincing. Of Mr. Bradby's three essays under the common title' By the Wayside,' the third, 'White, Black, and Grey,' is decidedly the best. For good tales-and several are really good-the reader will turn to the Marchesa Peruzzi de' Medici's description of her life in the house of her father, the sculptor Julian Story, at Rome, where Hans Andersen and Robert Browning both figure; and also to Sir Henry Lucy's wonted 'Sixty Years in the Wilderness.' "The Illustrious Garrison,' by Lieut.-Col. MacMunn, gives in a sufficiently telling way the story of Sale's Brigade at Jellalabad; and there is a short story, Pride of Service,' by Mr. Boyd Cable, of which the stuff, and also the descriptive treatment, are excellent; indeed, it wants only firmer, less amateurish handling of the characters at the climax to give it a claim to quite outstanding praise. Just a year ago we commented sympathetically on an excellent article by Mr. Hesketh Frichard about the Grey Seals of Haskeir. We congratulate both him and the editor of The Cornhill upon the effect of that article, which, through the intermediation of Mr. Charles Lyell. M.P.. stung the Legislature into legislating." and has brought to pass the Grey Seals (Protection) Bill. This has now gone through its third reading in the House of Lords, and provides a close season for grey seals from 1 October to 15 December. 66 THE July number of The Nineteenth Century is one of the best of recent years. The Abbé Ernest Dimnet has an article, important for its literary as well as for its social information, on the question | "Does the Church play any Active Part in France?' The situation, as he depicts it, is of unique interest. The history of religion may often be shown by the historian to repeat itself. The position of the Church in France to-day would seem to be in all literalness unprecedented. Miss Edith Sichel gives | us an attractive account of the late Emily Lawless; and Mr. Darrell Figgis draws from the volumes recently given to the world by Mrs. Parnell a portrait of Charles Stewart Parnell, which certainly explains his peculiar effectiveness, as the descriptions of him prior to the publication of this new life do not. One of the most charming papers in the number-and of a type to please, we think, many of our readers-is Mrs. Stirling's 'A Georgian Scrap-book,' this being a book of extracts compiled by Diana Bosville, daughter of one Yorkshire squire and wife of another, and a friend of Lady Mary Wortley Montagu's. Diana had a discerning eye in the matter of excerpts, and a brisk sense of humour, and the matter here selected out from her selections is most of it eminently worth while. Miss Arabella Kenealy contributes a lengthy and fascinating answer in the affirmative to the query 'Is Man an Electrical Organism?' stating, with considerable ingenuity and force, speculations which seem everywhere in the air about us just now. Miss Gertrude Kingston is a trenchant critic of the last three generations: her opinions seem to have been formed almost too exclusively from what she has observed in one stratum of society, and in, perhaps, only some of the circles even of this. Her warning note about the schoolboys of the present generation certainly deserves attention. to IN the July Fortnightly Count Ilya Tolstoy continues his reminiscences of his father, the naïve and homely record still of early childhood, with nothing in it unparalleled, but fairly interesting as to the details given. There is an account of the family sayings which became, within the family, proverbial, and this suggests that it would be interesting to have a collection of these started, no matter from what family, so they were properly Mr. Gilbert Coleauthenticated and genuine. ridge contributes a charming paper on Sir Thomas Browne, a personage whom it never seems wearisome repeatedly to contemplate. Prof. Gaston us M. Jean Richepin's Sévrette interprets interpretation of Shakespeare-correcting parts of it where he deems it needs correction, as, for example, in the matter of Desdemona's character, whom M. Richepin, perversely we also think, will have to be "curious, super-subtle," intellectuelle." Mr. J. F. Macdonald admires Mr. Zangwill's play Plaster Saints,' and gives his reasons for doing so in a skilful analysis. William Archer's Manners in India, and Mr. Wilfrid Ward's 'Oxford Liberalism and Dogma,' are perhaps not so far beyond the scope of 'N. & Q.' that we must forbear to mention them, being as they are very well worth consideration. The remaining papers are on national and international political questions, Notices to Correspondents. an Mr. ON all communications must be written the name and address of the sender, not necessarily for pub. lication, but as a guarantee of good faith. To secure insertion of communications corre spondents must observe the following rules. Let each note, query, or reply be written on a separate slip of paper, with the signature of the writer and such address as he wishes to appear. When answering queries, or making notes with regard to previous entries in the paper, contributors are requested to put in parentheses, immediately after the exact heading, the series, volume, and page or pages to which they refer. Correspondents who repeat queries are requested to head the second com munication " Duplicate." THE THE ATHENÆUM was established in 1828, and has achieved an unprecedented continuity of policy. That policy has been the unprejudiced criticism of Literature, combined with notices as they take place of the more important Fine Art Exhibitions, Scientific Meetings, Plays, and To those who desire to obtain adequate knowledge and unbiased criticism of the subjects CAMBRIDGE NOTES. THE EDITIO PRINCEPS OF THE 'QUÆSTIO DE AQUA ET TERRA.' SCIENCE-ROBERT BOYLE. MEMORIALS OF H. FORBES JULIAN. THE NATURE OF FINE ARTS-MEXICAN ARCHEOLOGY. CURRENT EXHIBITIONS. THE ROMAN DRAMA-CHAPMAN'S PLAYS AND POEMS. GOSSIP. |